razaar
Well-known member
It may have been Butch who changed Norman's pivot.Tons of pros get stuck on high pressure shots. Scottie has been swinging that way likely his entire life with tons of success at every level. I don't really agree that his swing doesn't have longevity or will be injury prone.
A lot of best pros in history and currently have what would be considered technical "flaws" in their golf swings. However, I consider it more of that is just their own golf swing that developed from just playing rather than getting too overly technical to make their swings technically correct. Don't get me wrong, the technically correct golf swing has complete merit, but not everyone can physically have the technically correct golf swing. There are many ways to swing the club and produce repeatable quality golf shots.
That is why I think Butch Harmon is one of the best. He works with what the player has and doesn't go to far out of the limitations and boundaries of what the player can do physically. He is not necessarily trying make every player swing the perfect golf swing. There are a lot of instructors that have a specific ideology of their perfect golf swing and try to make every player swing that way, but it is just is not possible for everyone.
The most famous slider was Byron Nelson. In his book he acknowledged that he took it to the extreme to the point that it was almost a fault.
Instruction books with the exception of Hogan's FIVE LESSONS..... taught the lateral pivot. Golf instructors taught a lateral hip bump to change direction up until the biomechanics got involved during the Tiger era.
Tennis went through a similar technical reconstruction before golf where it changed from a side on action to a rotation action.