Recipe Double Layer Pumpkin Pie

[Duffer Seamus]

In response to the responses to my post in the "Best Thanksgiving Pie?" thread, here is Keebler's recipe for the pie my wife makes each Thanksgiving: Keebler Double Layer Pumpkin Pie Recipe.

It's very tasty

I'll be posting photos of the one my wife makes on or around Thanksgiving Day

 

[ddec]

subscribed

 

[War Eagle]

I wish I knew how to bake.

 

[Duffer Seamus]

I wish I knew how to bake.

Ah, but, there's no need. From the description in the recipe...

Although this pie has the delicious flavors of a Thanksgiving Day pumpkin pie, it also sports an opulent no-bake cheesecake layer.

You just mix each of the two layers, layer it up in the pre-baked Keebler pie crust, and stick it in the fridge for a few hours to firm-up.

It's all in the recipe.

 

[Muchmore]

Oh. My. Goodness

 

[CBaker]

Is this basically a pumpkin pie, over a cheesecake?!

 

[War Eagle]

Ah, but, there's no need. From the description in the recipe...



You just mix each of the two layers, layer it up in the pre-baked Keebler pie crust, and stick it in the fridge for a few hours to firm-up.

It's all in the recipe.

No excuses now!

 

[Duffer Seamus]

Is this basically a pumpkin pie, over a cheesecake?!

Kind of. The bottom layer, being a mix of creme cheese and Cool Whip, is more a light, airy cheesecake-ish consistency. The top layer is likewise somewhat less dense than that of typical pumpkin pie.

No excuses now!

Nope It's so easy I could do it, and I have zero kitchen skills.

 

[outlawx]

Love this idea. Going to try it with a baked cheese cake and pumpkin pie

 

[rlew]

10/10

 

[Duffer Seamus]

Love this idea. Going to try it with a baked cheese cake and pumpkin pie

Will be interesting to hear how it turns out

 

[outlawx]

Will be interesting to hear how it turns out

I'll post back if you're interested

 

[ddec]

@War Eagle sounds like we need to do a no bake bake off

 

[mtbloco]

would eat

 

[War Eagle]

@War Eagle sounds like we need to do a no bake bake off

I can give it a go.

 

[PiratePenguin]

 

[ddec]

I can give it a go.

 

[War Eagle]

When are we doing this? We will have to present pictures.

 

[outlawx]

Densities of the cheesecake and pumpkin pie filling are different so I couldn't just pour on top. Very sad. Looks like I'll have to two step bake it. Your recipe seems superior

 

[Duffer Seamus]

Densities of the cheesecake and pumpkin pie filling are different so I couldn't just pour on top. Very sad. Looks like I'll have to two step bake it.

Yeah, that's what my wife said when I told her what you planned. And that double-bake would be tricky--if it's even possible.

Your recipe seems superior

Certainly much easier

 

[outlawx]

Yeah, that's what my wife said when I told her what you planned. And that double-bake would be tricky--if it's even possible.

Certainly much easier

Cracking is much worse too due to the difference in the layers.

 

[Duffer Seamus]

Cracking is much worse too due to the difference in the layers.

Marble pie? Be interesting to see how it cuts, serves, and tastes. Might be great

 

[MSEASU]

Thanks I’ll give it to my wife.

 

[outlawx]

Marble pie? Be interesting to see how it cuts, serves, and tastes. Might be great

lol I need a few days to report back

 

[ddec]

@War Eagle I'm getting ready